Job Search

Why Do Companies Post Ghost Jobs? (Are They Illegal? How to Spot One)

What ghost jobs are, why companies post them (with the surveys behind the claims), every ghost job law and bill with its official status, a copyable checklist to spot one and a script to ask a recruiter.

EREmpire Resume Team·Nov 17, 2026·14 min read

A ghost job is a posting for a role that doesn’t exist or that the company isn’t actively trying to fill. Companies post them to collect resumes, look like they’re growing, or go through the motions before hiring an insider. In the U.S. they aren’t illegal: no state ghost-job law is in force, though New York’s legislature has passed one.

Legal status as of November 17, 2026

  • Federal (U.S.): no ghost-job law. The Congressional Research Service reported in April 2025 that no bill explicitly addressing ghost job postings had been introduced in Congress, and a search of 119th Congress bill text on GovInfo on November 17, 2026 found none either. Deceptive job ads can still fall under Section 5 of the FTC Act, but CRS notes that proving an employer’s intent to hire is difficult.
  • New York: passed, not yet law. S8877 / A6292A passed the Senate on April 28, 2026 and the Assembly on June 2, 2026. As of November 17, 2026 the Assembly’s bill record shows no delivery to the governor, so Governor Hochul hasn’t signed or vetoed it.
  • New Jersey: pending. A1161 is in the Assembly Commerce and Economic Development Committee (since March 16, 2026). Its Senate twin, S2136, is in Senate Budget and Appropriations (since May 11, 2026).
  • California, Kentucky, Pennsylvania: bills introduced, none passed (details below).
  • Ontario, Canada: in force. Since January 1, 2026, employers with 25 or more employees must say in each public job posting whether it’s for an existing vacancy, and must tell interviewed applicants within 45 days whether a hiring decision has been made.
  • Who decides next: the New York governor (once the bill is delivered), and committees in New Jersey. We re-check every official bill page monthly.

Ghost job laws and bills: the full tracker

Jurisdiction Bill or law What it would require Status (as of Nov 17, 2026) Official source
Ontario, Canada Employment Standards Act, 2000, ss. 8.5 and 8.6; O. Reg. 476/24 Each public posting must state whether it’s for an existing vacancy. Interviewed applicants must be told within 45 days of their last interview whether a hiring decision has been made. Employers with fewer than 25 employees are exempt. In force since January 1, 2026 ESA, 2000 on e-Laws; O. Reg. 476/24
New York S8877 (Gianaris) / A6292A (Jacobson) Employers with 100+ employees and job boards must state in capital letters whether the posting is for a current vacancy and when the employer intends to fill it, or that it isn’t for a current vacancy. Filled postings come down within two weeks. Fine of $2,500 per publication or platform, rising to $5,000 if not fixed within 30 days. Passed both houses (Senate April 28, 2026; Assembly June 2, 2026). Not yet delivered to the governor. NY Assembly bill record, A6292A / S8877
New Jersey A1161 (Danielsen, Speight) / S2136 (Moriarty) Employers with more than 10 employees must disclose whether a posting is for an existing vacancy and an estimated time to fill, remove filled postings within two weeks, and update interviewed applicants. As introduced: a warning, then penalties of $1,000 to $5,000. In committee. A1161 reported with amendments March 16, 2026, now in Assembly Commerce and Economic Development. S2136 reported with amendments May 11, 2026, now in Senate Budget and Appropriations. A1161 text; NJ Legislature bill search
California AB 1251 (Berman) As introduced, private employers would have to state whether a posting is for an existing vacancy. Amended in the Senate on June 26, 2025 to intent language only. Held in Senate Appropriations (held under submission August 29, 2025), with no action recorded since. The session’s last day to pass bills, August 31, 2026, has passed. Check with the California Legislature (status confirmed via CalMatters Digital Democracy; we couldn’t open leginfo directly)
Kentucky HB 342 (Willner, Kulkarni), 2026 session Would ban posting ghost jobs, with a penalty. Died in committee. Last action January 21, 2026 (referred to Economic Development and Workforce Investment). The 2026 regular session has adjourned. Kentucky General Assembly, HB 342
Pennsylvania HB 2321 (Prokopiak and 18 cosponsors) Job posting requirements with penalties (“Banning Ghost Job Postings”). In committee. Referred to House Labor and Industry March 26, 2026; no votes. The 2025-2026 session ends November 30, 2026. Pennsylvania General Assembly, HB 2321
United States (federal) None No bill introduced, per CRS. No federal bill found CRS In Focus IF12977, “Ghost” Job Postings (April 25, 2025)

We read each bill record on the official legislature site on November 17, 2026, except California, where the official site blocked our tools.

What is a ghost job?

The Congressional Research Service, Congress’s nonpartisan research arm, defines ghost job postings as “online job postings for positions that do not exist, or that employers are not planning to fill immediately.” In my experience, they come in four flavors:

  • Pipeline or “evergreen” postings. The company is always collecting resumes for a role it hires for now and then. There may be no opening today.
  • Stale reposts. The job was filled, but the listing lives on, often because a job board copied it automatically and the employer only took down the original. CRS points out that this is a common way ghost jobs happen without anyone meaning to deceive.
  • Formality postings. The company already has an internal candidate but posts externally to show it ran an open process.
  • Fake postings. Scammers impersonating real employers, or staffing agencies advertising jobs to build a candidate pool. These overlap with job scams, which are a different (and already illegal) problem.

A ghost job is not the same as getting “ghosted.” Ghosting is when an employer stops responding to you. That can happen on a real job too.

Why do companies post ghost jobs?

CRS lists the main reasons: to size up the candidate pool or collect resumes for later, to suggest the company is growing (to employees or investors), to show they recruited a broad pool before hiring an internal candidate, or to look for an exceptional hire. The survey data behind those reasons comes mostly from companies that sell hiring products, so read it with that in mind.

Survey Who ran it Who they asked What they found
Resume Builder, May 2024 A resume-writing company (vendor survey, run on Pollfish) 1,641 hiring managers screened, 649 completed the full survey 40% said their company posted a fake job listing in the past year. Among those companies, the top reasons were to look open to external talent (67%), look like it’s growing (66%), make employees think help was coming (63%), make employees feel replaceable (62%) and collect resumes for later (59%).
Clarify Capital, August 31 to September 1, 2022 A small-business lender (vendor survey) 1,045 managers involved in hiring 68% had postings active more than 30 days. 50% kept postings open because they’re “always open to new people,” and 43% said they weren’t actively trying to fill some positions because they wanted to keep employees motivated or look like they were growing.
Greenhouse, The Hire Standard, fall 2026 An applicant tracking software company (customer data, not a survey) 161.8 million applications across 9,473 U.S. companies, January to August 2026 One in three openings closed with no one hired. That’s not proof of ghost jobs (roles get cut or paused), but it shows how often a real-looking opening ends with no hire.

Sources: Resume Builder survey, Clarify Capital survey, Greenhouse Hire Standard. All opened November 17, 2026.

Why companies said they posted fake jobsLook open to outside talent67%Look like it’s growing66%Make staff think help is coming63%Make staff feel replaceable62%Collect resumes for later59%Source: Resume Builder survey of hiring managers, May 2024 (vendor survey). Base: companies that posted a fake job.

How common are ghost jobs, really?

Nobody knows, and anyone who gives you a precise national percentage is guessing. CRS says plainly that “there are no official statistics on the magnitude of ghost jobs,” and that the firms publishing estimates “market hiring-related services, including job posting verification tools” and share varying levels of methodology.

Here’s the one reassuring part. The government’s official count of job openings, the BLS JOLTS survey, only counts a job as open if a specific position exists, it could start within 30 days, and the employer is actively recruiting outside workers. So when you read that there were 7.52 million openings in September 2026, that’s a cleaner number than the listings you scroll past. We break down that data in why it’s so hard to get a job right now.

Are ghost jobs illegal?

In the United States, posting a ghost job isn’t specifically illegal anywhere yet. Here’s how the law stands, layer by layer.

Federal law. There’s no federal ghost-job statute. Section 5 of the FTC Act bans “unfair or deceptive acts or practices,” and the FTC has gone after fake job placement schemes. But CRS explains why that doesn’t easily reach ghost jobs: an employer’s intent to hire “is not easily discoverable and may be subjective, making proof of deception difficult.” Employers also generally have no legal duty to respond to applicants, though treating applicants differently based on a protected characteristic can violate Title VII.

New York is closest. If Governor Hochul signs S8877, New York would be the first U.S. state with a ghost-job law. Postings by employers with 100 or more employees, and by job boards, would have to carry one of three statements in capital letters and bold type, for example “THIS POSTING IS FOR A CURRENT VACANCY AND THE EMPLOYER INTENDS TO FILL THIS POSITION BY (DATE).” Government employers are excluded. The bill says it takes effect immediately once signed.

New Jersey goes furthest on paper. A1161 would cover employers with more than 10 employees, including the state, and would require employers to tell interviewed applicants whether the job was filled within the timeframe in the ad. It’s still in committee, and the committee amendments may have changed the penalties from the introduced text.

Ontario already has rules. If you’re applying to jobs in Ontario, employers with 25 or more employees must say whether each public posting is for an existing vacancy, disclose if they use AI to screen applicants, and tell you within 45 days of your last interview whether they’ve made a hiring decision. Internal-only postings, general “help wanted” signs and general recruitment campaigns are excluded.

Job scams are already illegal. A fake posting meant to steal your money or identity is fraud. If a “recruiter” asks you to pay for equipment, training or a background check, or wants your bank details before an offer, stop and report it at the FTC’s ReportFraud site.

We’re not lawyers. Empire Resume is an independent editorial team, not a law firm, and we aren’t affiliated with any legislature or labor department. This page is general information, not legal advice. Bill statuses change, so check the official bill page linked in the tracker before relying on one, and for help with a specific situation contact your state labor department or find free legal aid at LawHelp.org. Reviewed on November 17, 2026.

How to spot a ghost job: a 10-point checklist

Copy this into your notes and run each posting through it before you spend an hour on a tailored application. Three or more red flags means I’d verify the job is real (script below) before applying.

GHOST JOB CHECKLIST (red flag = check the box)

[ ] 1. Posted or reposted more than 30 days ago, or reposted
       several times with the same description.
[ ] 2. Not on the company's own careers page, or the careers page
       shows it as closed.
[ ] 3. No requisition or job ID anywhere in the listing.
[ ] 4. Vague duties ("various projects," "support the team") with
       no team, manager title or location detail.
[ ] 5. No pay range in a place that requires one, or a range so
       wide it means nothing.
[ ] 6. The company recently announced layoffs or a hiring freeze
       but keeps posting the same roles.
[ ] 7. Huge applicant count and the listing stays up for weeks.
[ ] 8. Language like "always accepting applications," "talent
       pool" or "future opportunities."
[ ] 9. No named recruiter or hiring manager, and no way to reach
       a person.
[ ] 10. You applied to the same role before and never heard back,
        and it is still up.

None of these proves a job is fake. Pipeline postings (flag 8) can be honest, and a 45-day-old posting might be a hard-to-fill role. The checklist is about deciding where to put your limited time.

LinkedIn ghost jobs: what to check

Searches for “LinkedIn ghost jobs” have jumped this year, and LinkedIn is where most people notice them. On LinkedIn specifically, I’d check three things: whether the listing says it was reposted, whether the same role appears on the company’s own careers site, and whether you can find the recruiter or hiring manager on the platform. If the role only exists as a LinkedIn listing and nobody at the company seems to own it, treat it as unverified.

Script: how to ask a recruiter if a job is still open

It’s completely fine to ask. Recruiters get this question often, and a clear question gets a clear answer more often than you’d think. Keep it short and neutral.

EMAIL OR LINKEDIN MESSAGE

Subject: Question about the [Job Title] role (Req [ID if listed])

Hi [Name],

I'm interested in the [Job Title] role on your team and want to
make sure my application is timely. Could you tell me:

1. Is the position open and approved to hire right now?
2. What's your target start date or timeline to fill it?
3. Is the team considering external candidates, or is there
   already a strong internal candidate?

I'm happy to send my resume directly if that helps.

Thanks,
[Your name]
[Phone] | [LinkedIn URL]
PHONE SCREEN VERSION (ask near the end)

"Before we wrap up, can I ask a couple of quick questions about
the role itself? Is this a new position or a backfill? Is it
approved and budgeted right now? And what does your timeline
look like for making an offer?"

How to read the answer:

  • A date and a reason (“backfill, approved, we’d like someone by January”): real and active. Prioritize it.
  • “We’re always looking for great people”: probably a pipeline posting. Apply if it’s a strong fit, but don’t count on it.
  • No answer after one follow-up a week later: move on. Silence isn’t proof of a ghost job, but your time is better spent elsewhere.

What to do instead of chasing ghost jobs

The best defense is to rely less on cold postings. A large share of hires happen through referrals and internal moves, as we cover in how many jobs are filled from advertised positions. Pair that with direct outreach: our guide to finding jobs that aren’t posted on job boards shows how to find the hiring manager and reach out before a role is even posted.

If you’re job hunting after a layoff, the posting problem is only one piece. Check whether you were laid off or fired (it changes what you’re owed), whether you can expect severance pay, and what to do with your 401(k) when you leave a job.

How we keep this page current

We re-check every bill in the tracker on its official legislature page each month, and right away when one of these happens:

Event When we expect it What changes on this page
New York S8877 delivered to the governor Any time before the end of the 2026 session year; once delivered after the legislature adjourns, the governor has 30 days to act Status box, tracker row, “Are ghost jobs illegal” section
Pennsylvania session ends November 30, 2026 HB 2321 marked dead unless it moves
California 2027-2028 session opens December 2026 Check for a reintroduced ghost-job bill
Kentucky and other legislatures convene January 2027 Check for new bills
New Jersey A1161 or S2136 leaves committee No date set (the session runs through 2027) Tracker row and penalties
New CRS update or a federal bill on congress.gov Unscheduled Federal row and status box

FAQ

What are ghost jobs?

Ghost jobs are job postings for roles that don’t exist or that the employer isn’t actively trying to fill. They include pipeline postings, stale reposts of filled jobs, formality postings for an internal hire, and fake listings.

Why do companies post ghost jobs?

Mostly to collect resumes for later, to look like they’re growing, to signal to employees that help is coming or that they’re replaceable, or to show they ran an open search before promoting someone internally. Those reasons come from CRS and from vendor surveys of hiring managers.

Are ghost jobs illegal?

Not in the U.S. as of November 17, 2026. New York’s legislature passed a ghost-job bill (S8877) that hasn’t reached the governor yet, and New Jersey has bills in committee. Ontario, Canada has required existing-vacancy disclosure since January 1, 2026. Fake postings used for scams are already illegal fraud.

Are ghost jobs illegal in New York?

Not yet. S8877 passed both houses in 2026 but, as of November 17, 2026, hadn’t been delivered to or signed by the governor. If it becomes law, employers with 100 or more employees would have to state whether a posting is for a current vacancy and when they intend to fill it.

How can you tell if a job posting is a ghost job?

Look for a posting that’s old or repeatedly reposted, missing from the company’s careers page, has no requisition ID, uses vague duties, or says “always accepting applications.” The surest way is to ask the recruiter whether the role is approved and when they want someone to start.

What is the 70/30 rule in hiring?

There’s no official 70/30 rule. People use the phrase loosely, often for the idea that you should apply if you meet about 70% of the requirements. It isn’t a law or a standard recruiters follow, so don’t let it stop you from applying when you meet the core must-haves.

What is the 3 month rule for jobs?

There’s no legal “3 month rule.” People use it for different ideas, such as giving a new job three months before judging it, or the 90-day probationary period some employers use. For job postings specifically, New York’s bill uses a 90-day line: postings would have to say whether the employer intends to fill the job within 90 days or later.

What is the hardest month to get hired?

There’s no official ranking. Hiring at many employers slows around the year-end holidays and picks up after budgets reset, but it varies by industry. Government hiring data is seasonally adjusted, which removes those swings, so it can’t settle this one either.

The bottom line

Ghost jobs are real, nobody can measure exactly how common they are, and in the U.S. they’re still legal. Until New York or another state puts a law into effect, protect your time: run postings through the checklist, ask the recruiter one direct question, and put more of your energy into referrals and outreach. When you find a role that’s real, make your application count. Our free resume analysis gets a person to read your resume and tell you what to fix first.

See how your resume scores
Get a free, no-obligation analysis and specific fixes before your next application.
Free resume analysis
ER
Written by
Empire Resume Team
Recruiters and career coaches. About the team

Related guides